Showing posts with label George Bailey. Show all posts
Showing posts with label George Bailey. Show all posts

Saturday, November 30, 2013

Banking Is Not Small Business Saturday

The holidays are upon us and the public relations blitz is on so we patronize small businesses for Christmas shopping. Why? Do small businesses have a unique value proposition that larger stores do not? Or are we relying on nostalgia and some David versus Goliath goodwill to drive us into the arms of local shops?

I have news for you. The latter is a failed business idea. For example, in my town, we have two relatively small lumber yards only because the NIMBY's kept Lowes out. If Lowes secured the necessary permits to open shop, bye bye small lumberyards. So the local owners think they perpetuated their business model by keeping out a competitor. How about offering something customers value greater than price, Mr. Lumberyard Owner?

Walk into a Lowes, and you are overwhelmed with the selection, and probably have difficulty finding somebody knowledgeable to help you with what you need for your project. If somebody does help you, there is often a line of people waiting for that worker's attention. Why doesn't the local owner differentiate there? But no. My wife refuses to go to one of the lumberyards because the workers' treat her like she doesn't know what she's talking about. In other words, they chose not to deliver something valued by customers. 

Are we that much different in community banking? Do we rely on some "feel-good" marketing message to drive customers to us instead of Wells Fargo? Do we hope that George Bailey will deliver us from irrelevance? Why should customers bank with you instead of the omni-present Bank of America? Because I got news for you... they haven't. The top 50 banks in the USA, less than 1% of all banks, boast 76% of all banking assets. 

The people have voted, and community banks are losing.

Why? Because we have difficulty answering the question "why bank with us"? Sure, we'll come up with some answer that says "service" or something intangible and, apparently based on the facts, unnoticeable. But have we really identified what differentiates or can differentiate us from the big boys, and built the systems, processes, and people around delivering on that promise?

Or do we keep telling ourselves in management meetings that we have better service than them, and then break into a loan committee meeting to lower our price or terms on a commercial real estate deal we're trying to win from PNC?

Don't rely on your own Small Business Saturday so customers bank with you because they are sympathetic for you.

So I ask you: why bank with you?

~ Jeff


Note: After penning this post I read an article about Small Business Saturday that said $68 of every $100 spent in local small businesses was re-spent in the community. For chain stores and online stores, that stat was $48 and $0, respectively. So there's a good part of the story to build on, in addition to creating a value proposition that customers care about. Also a good lesson for community financial institutions. How much deposit money is re-invested locally compared to the big boys? Don't forget about the in addition to...

Wednesday, December 21, 2011

It's a Wonderful Life

This 1946 Christmas classic is a story about the impact one man made on his family, his business, and his community. It goes beyond the fate of the Bailey Building and Loan. It teaches us to take stock of our lives, to be helpful instead of hurtful, and be thankful for what we have instead of stressed over what we don't.

But It's a Wonderful Life is also a testament to the importance of community financial institutions (FIs). The classic scene of the run on the Bailey Building and Loan after the 1929 stock market crash depicts the basic principals of community banking, how FIs work, and how important character plays in bank lending and community development.


What you don't see here is the villainous Mr. Potter's diatribe on how the Bailey Building and Loan advanced loans to "riff-raff", and was unwilling to foreclose when the "rabble" ran into difficulty making payments. Instead, the Bailey's modified the terms to help borrowers make it through tough patches.

What you also don't see is the bank examiner showing up to review the bank's books. Note the examiner wasn't plowing through the loan portfolio and criticizing this underwriting anomaly or that. He was there to ensure what the bank reported in its footings was accurate. In the end, Uncle Billy Bailey loses $8,000 when depositing the funds in the correspondent bank; Mr. Potter's bank. It was the mismatch in footings that landed George Bailey in hot water with the examiners. It wasn't lax underwriting, or troubled debt restructurings.

When the Bedford Falls community pulls together to raise the missing $8,000, they toast George as the "richest man in town". The bank examiner actually contributed to the pot of money. My how times have changed.

It's a Wonderful Life portrays the significance a financial institution plays in elevating the socio-economic status of local residents. The working poor increase their wealth by owning cars so they can get to work, to go to college or technical school, and/or to achieve home ownership. The middle class can improve their wealth by upsizing their home, going to grad school, and/or starting a business. Many of these loans don't fit the one-size fits all underwriting criteria of government bureaucrats whose sole objective is to cover their butts should asset quality falter in an institution they examine. "Rabble" need not apply.

In this sense, regulators that examine our financial institutions are the modern day Mr. Potter. But in order to help businesses work through difficult economic times, to help families stay afloat during periods of unemployment, and to help communities re-adjust to remain economically vibrant during changing times, we need more Bailey Building and Loans, not less.

Is anybody listening?

~ Jeff

Note: Since this post, the NY Times wrote an article about a modern day Bailey Building & Loan: Bank of Cattaraugus. Cattaraugus, coincidentally, is in upstate NY, near Buffalo. Perhaps not too far from the fictional Bedford Falls. Although I salute the Bank for its success in helping local people, I do believe community FIs can achieve long-term success through the profit motive, which is consistent with operating in vibrant communities.

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/12/25/nyregion/the-bank-of-cattaraugus-new-york-states-smallest-bank-plays-an-outsize-role.html?_r=1&adxnnl=1&ref=nyregion&pagewanted=all&adxnnlx=1325347237-Q5F/vRUqZwymOgvBcu0zFg